httpss://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/17SCnwH1pGDp9-6IOKOvkIwcqqRz7AQ1Qmw2vk7xxmQo/edit#gid=25Disclaimer: A lot of the ratings are incorrect and I'm well aware of this. I will not update the spreadsheet because I'm working on exporting it over to my website. When the website launches, I will close the spreadsheet and give the games a proper rating as well as overhauling the system.
This is my list of completed fangames
Each game has its own "mini-review" and lists the difficulty from 1-10 stars, the genre, whether it's fun or not and it even provides a download link (if there's one available)
You can click on some of the game titles for a video, sometimes just the final boss and sometimes a full playthrough or even a speedrun.
I rate the games based on how good I think they are, not how much I enjoyed them. I could hate a game but still rate it highly and I could also love a game but rate it lower than you might expect.
The list is designed to make you pick and choose what games you want to play and will hopefully eventually be an alternative to the wiki.
If you have feedback, please post it here!