Fangames > User-Made Creations

I Wanna Kill The BLB [Shukuteki Tamatou]

<< < (4/7) > >>

pieceofcheese87:
T O X I C C O M M U N I T Y
O X I C C O M M U N I T Y
X I C C O M M U N I T Y
I C C O M M U N I T Y
C C O M M U N I T Y
C O M M U N I T Y
O M M U N I T Y
M M U N I T Y
M U N I T Y
U N I T Y
N I T Y
I T Y
T Y
Y

bananaguy12:
I played the game up to the boss. I didn't really find it very funny, and I'm assuming it has a bunch of in-jokes that I don't get, if you said it was made for your friends. I don't like how it put me in full screen at first, but maybe that only happened to me for some reason. The boss seemed kind of cool, though I only played it for a minute so I can't really give feedback on it. Rating: 4/10.

Derf:
@tehjman1993:

Pointlessly slamming a game from an obviously novice creator, then trying to assert that there's some moral objective in doing so (because obviously this game has and will lead to people disrespecting the wiki) and finally copping out of the discussion by pretending you don't care (even though you cared enough to write that response) is one of the most farcical things I've seen in a long time.

Is this game satirical? Yes it is. As the creator said, it takes non-existent games and makes a medley game out of them (an idea that's actually really interesting). But is the sarcasm involved somehow damaging to the reputation of the fangaming community? No it isn't, and if you really believe what you were saying in that vein then I implore you to develop some thick skin. The truth is, facets of this community do take themselves too seriously, and I think it's good we have more light-hearted creations to poke fun at them.

I agree with your general belief that there is a level of quality fangames should meet in terms of effort put in (and that it's insulting to the patrons of the wiki to upload such things; Bobby I'm looking at you), but I don't believe there is a set tone or level of seriousness fangames should meet. While I think the flaws of this fangame far outweigh the pros, you cannot tell me it hasn't had any effort put into it. The level of quality we should not be accepting is things that have clearly taken people no time at all and are only designed to infuriate or troll; this game was clearly designed to be played like a proper game, however facetiously it presents itself. This is a topic where there is decent discussion to be had, provided it doesn't stem from some stubborn defence of a comment it's clear not even you believe.

Tamatou is learning the ropes and having fun. I'm sorry that your level of patience has dropped so low you can no longer tolerate creations below a certain threshold, it's understandable with a lot of detritus that's been on the wiki lately, but there's really no reason to slam young and new creators who are obviously trying.


-------------------------

As for the game, here's my opinion:

Pros:
- The idea itself is interesting.
- There is a level of effort involved here.
- I found the first room pretty funny tbh.

Cons:
- Immediately pushed into fullscreen at the beginning for a silly intro that really shouldn't be there.
- Why is it 200mb+ and why is this all in the application as opposed to being loaded externally? It doesn't seem like you took any of the advice given in the thread about your music problems.
- The load screen + intro combine to give the game a less than appealing beginning (and this is precisely the kind of thing that people who make snapshot judgements before playing something properly will immediately jump on this to try and justify their opinions).
- Troll games are a fine balance. They need to have a level of annoyance involved but this needs to be kept low in order to maintain the player's enjoyment; it goes overboard a bit here.

I didn't finish it, I don't plan to. I didn't think it was terrible Tamatou, if the jokes were stripped back a bit and the in-jokes were removed this might be quite a charming little game. I hope you continue to improve and make games with all the silliness and nice ideas but with a bit more care towards the player and towards production value.

bananaguy12:
...I'm not doing that stuff I just made a simple review. I hope you're not talking to me when you write this.

Kyir:

--- Quote from: bananaguy12 on October 09, 2015, 02:19:53 PM ---...I'm not doing that stuff I just made a simple review. I hope you're not talking to me when you write this.

--- End quote ---

You were clearly being way too harsh on this poor guy. How dare you.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page